Proposed cancer treatment may boost lung cancer stem cells, study warns

Epigenetic enzymes and lung cancer: Treating adenocarcinoma with G9a histone methyltransferase inhibitors leads to an increase in tumor cells with stem-like properties. In contrast, inhibiting histone demethylase prevents tumor growth. (SAMUEL ROWBOTHAM/BOSTON CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL)

Epigenetic therapies — targeting enzymes that alter what genes are turned on or off in a cell — are of growing interest in oncology as a way to make cancers less aggressive or less malignant. But now, at least one epigenetic therapy that had looked promising for lung cancer appears to boost the cancer stem cells that are believed to drive tumors. A study published today in Nature Communications also identifies a strategy that reduces these stem cells, curbing lung cancer in mice.

Cancer stem cells have been identified in blood cancers and a variety of solid tumors. They make up a tiny fraction of tumor cells, but can regenerate a cancer on their own. Carla Kim, PhD, and colleagues in the Stem Cell Research program at Boston Children’s Hospital have shown that cancer stem cells play a role in adenocarcinoma, the most common type of lung cancer. When they transplanted cancer stem cells from a diseased mouse, previously healthy mice developed lung cancer.

We found these drugs were making the surviving tumor cells more stem-like.The new study, led by lab member Samuel Rowbotham, PhD, focused on an epigenetic therapy that inhibits the enzyme G9a, a type of histone methyltransferase. G9a had been thought to be cancer-promoting, and some studies have suggested that inhibiting G9a is an effective strategy in certain cancers, including adenocarcinoma. Rowbotham and Kim now call this into question.

“People had looked at cell lines from lung tumors and found that they are sensitive to drugs inhibiting G9a,” says Rowbotham. “In general tumor cell populations, these drugs would slow down growth or even kill the cells. But we found that these drugs were also making the surviving tumor cells more stem-like. We predicted that this would advance disease progression, and this is what we saw.”

Beware the cancer stem cells

The team first looked at adenocarcinoma cell lines. They found that when the cells were treated with G9a, they became more like stem cells. Next, they transplanted cancer stem cells into live mice and tracked the development of adenocarcinoma. When they knocked down the G9a gene in lung tumors, the tumors grew bigger and spread farther.

Kim, also affiliated with the Division of Hematology/Oncology at Boston Children’s, believes this down side to G9a hadn’t been noticed because prior studies only looked at cell lines, and because cancer stem cells are hard to detect.

“Earlier studies couldn’t see that cancer stem cells were still around, and there’s more of them when you treat with these drugs,” she says. “Because they’re such a small fraction of the tumor, anything that affects them can easily be missed.”

A new epigenetic target?

But Rowbotham, Kim and colleagues also found potentially better enzymes to target: histone demethylases. Their action is chemically opposite to that of G9a, stripping off a methyl group from histone where G9a adds one. When Rowbotham knocked down the gene for demethylase enzymes, and added a drug that prevents them from working, the cells looked less like cancer stem cells in a dish and behaved less like cancer stem cells in live mice. When he gave demethylase inhibitors to mice with established lung tumors, cancer progression was slowed and the animals survived longer than untreated mice.

Kim and Rowbotham (PHOTO: MICHAEL GODERRE)

Although a cancer stem cell hasn’t been found in human adenocarcinoma, Kim believes the findings are worth pursuing further. She notes a related line of evidence — a 2017 study that found that demethylase inhibitors were effective in killing chemotherapy-resistant cells from patients’ tumors.

“Even if we can’t pinpoint cancer stem cells in human patients, Sam’s work shows you can start by studying a cancer stem cell in a mouse model and identify targets that could be clinically important,” she says. “It shows the importance of finding the right molecule the cancer is sensitive to. In adenocarcinoma, a demethylase inhibitor is likelier to be more useful than methyltransferase inhibitor.”

A two-phase cancer strategy?

Kim, Rowbotham and others envision a two-phase strategy for adenocarcinoma. It would first target the general population of cancer cells to “debulk” the tumor, then direct a second treatment specifically at cancer stem cells.

The team is now doing further studies to explore demethylase inhibitors as potential therapeutic drugs, alone or with other treatments. Because demethylase inhibitors have very broad effects, they will also look for genes the inhibitors affect downstream, which could provide more specific drug targets.

Kim is an executive committee member of the Harvard Stem Cell Institute. The study was funded by a IASLC Young Investigator Fellowship, the National Institutes of Health, the American Cancer Society, the V Foundation for Cancer Research, the Thoracic Foundation, the Ellison Foundation, the BCH-Broad Institute Award, Harvard Medical School, the Harvard Stem Cell Institute, the American Lung Association, the ATS and the National Cancer Institute. See the paper for a full list of authors and affiliations